Summer Solstice and Qualia
Datura in our front yard |
I watched the moon climb in the sky last night and illuminate the garden. In the foreground were some squash plants with this year's blossoms a sign of the food to come, and the work that the sun does to feed us. In the near background, the dried stems and seeds of tall grasses reminded me of last year's growth and last year's suns.
I had watered the plants in the garden shortly before the moon rose, and in the moonlight and waning light of the sun, birds flew down to perch on the fence, attracted to both the water and the insects that were themselves drawn by the water.
Moonrise over the garden on the Summer Solstice |
I would not at all describe myself as mystical in the sense of believing that there are things that cannot, in time, be described and explained by science. However, I do believe that there are multiple ways of describing things. For example, the color orange can be described scientifically, as can the process through which my eyes and brain create my experience of an instance of seeing orange. But while these things can be explained and described, they don't capture my direct, personal, subjective experience of an instance of orange, or the qualia (http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qualia/).
And I don't believe that the things I tell myself about those qualia are always true in the sense of describing anything about the world. It's critical to make the distinction between the qualia and the things I tell myself about them, the judgments I make about them, and especially the claims I'm tempted to make about the world from them. The qualia just are, they're my subjective experience; it would be incorrect to state that they're true or false, or that they by themselves reveal something about the world beyond my subjective experience of it.
So, when I have a spiritual experience of sorts, a feeling of oneness and connectedness, and a sense of awe about the world and me in it, that is a wonderful thing to experience and I seek out those kinds of experiences and cherish them. But I believe it would be a mistake for me to conclude merely from those experiences that I am one with the universe, that there is some transcendental universal spirit or something like that. I think it's important to keep in mind that to come to such conclusions is to take a step beyond the qualia and to take a stance about the truth or falseness of something, and that the qualia are not sufficient justification to do so.
Keeping this in mind does not at all diminish the value my experience. I still had an experience of awe and grace, beauty and oneness last night as the moon rose over the mountains, as light of the setting sun and the rising moon washed over the garden, and as the cottonwood seeds drifted over the river and across the road.
Comments
Post a Comment